Topwater Popper Fishing on Brookville Lake
Brookville Lake · Indiana · Midwest
Brookville Lake sits in the rolling hills of Franklin County, impounded by the Whitewater River and shaped by steep, rocky banks in its upper arms and flatter, more gradually tapering points in the lower pool. Water clarity trends cleaner than most Indiana reservoirs — visibility of 3 to 6 feet is common outside of heavy rainfall events — which gives the fishery more of an Ozarks character than the stained flood-control lakes of the western part of the state. Largemouth dominate the flatter coves and brush, but a legitimate smallmouth population lives along the rocky main-lake points and riprap, and spotted bass show up in the deeper, clearer stretches of the upper Whitewater arm.
A floating hard bait with a concave face that produces a spitting, popping action when twitched. Most effective in low-light conditions near cover — points, dock edges, weed lines, and grass pockets. The pause after the pop is where most strikes happen. Few experiences in fishing match watching a largemouth explode on a popper.
Topwater Popper Setup for Brookville Lake
| Rod | 6'10"–7'3" medium casting rod, moderate action |
| Reel | 6.4:1 baitcaster or spinning |
| Line | 14–17 lb fluorocarbon or 30 lb braid (braid gives better action and hooksets) |
| Weight | 1/4–1/2 oz (Rebel Pop-R, Megabass Pop-X, Strike King KVD Splash) |
Seasonal Tactics on Brookville Lake
Lake: Pre-spawn largemouth stage on secondary points and chunk rock in 6–12 ft before pushing into the backs of coves; a 3/8 oz Strike King Tour Grade football jig or swimbait worked along chunk rock transitions is the consistent producer when water temps hit the mid-50s. Smallmouth begin their own staging push onto gravel points in the upper arms around the same time, often two to three weeks behind the largemouth calendar.
Topwater Popper: First light on spawning flats — fish hold shallow and crush surface baits. Slow cadence with long pauses.
Lake: Bass push to main-lake structure and deeper channel edges in 15–22 ft as surface temps climb into the mid-80s; drop shots and finesse football jigs on the long main-lake points keep contact with suspended and bottom-holding fish when topwater action dies by 9 AM. Early morning topwater around main-lake docks and riprap can be exceptional through late June before the heat fully takes over.
Topwater Popper: 30-minute window at dawn and dusk. Fish dock shade and grass pockets. Noon topwater dies.
Lake: Shad-driven schooling action picks up on the main lake in September and October, with bass running baitfish to the surface near channel swings and the mouths of major coves; a 1/2 oz white or chrome War Eagle spinnerbait or a Heddon Super Spook Jr. covers water fast during these windows. As water cools below 60°F, fish stack back on chunk rock points and transition to slower jig and swimbait presentations.
Topwater Popper: Extended feeding window as water cools. Fish can be caught on top all day in fall.
Lake: Winter fishing at Brookville slows considerably but doesn't shut down for patient anglers willing to work a Ned rig or finesse drop shot on main-lake points in 20–28 ft; fish school tightly in the cleaner water, and locating one often means locating a dozen. Water temps in January and February typically sit in the low-to-mid 40s, demanding counts of 10–15 seconds on any bottom bait before the next move.
Topwater Popper: Generally ineffective in water below 55°F — bass won't chase topwater in cold conditions.
Best Conditions
Dawn and dusk year-round, overcast days, calm to light-chop surface, spring through fall near cover and grass edges
Don't set the hook on the explosion — wait until you feel the fish pull the line. Half of all missed popper strikes are from anglers jerking too early.
More Techniques for Brookville Lake
Ready to fish Brookville Lake?
Ask Hank about current conditions, water temp, and exactly what to throw today.
Ask Hank →